All sources are biased you need to explain what biases are inherent in the source and how the historian should account for them

Primary Source Analysis

Primary Source AnalysisInstructions and Grading RubricPrimary sources are the key tools a historian has at his or her disposal. Without primary evidence that is to say evidence that is contemporary to the time period under investigation the historian has no means of attempting to reconstruct what happened in the past. For this reason assessment of your ability to interpret primary source material forms an important part of this course (and other courses you will take at UIS).When analyzing primary sources it is critical to remember that your source will have its strengths and  its  weaknesses.  A  pamphlet  denouncing  the  British  governments  Stamp  Act  of  1765  might  be useful in explaining a number of question how the author felt about taxation policy for example or why  there  were  increasing  tensions  between  Britain  and  America  at  the  start  of  the  American Revolution.  It  would  not  be  at  all  useful  if  you  were  hoping  to  write  about  the  uses  agricultural technology in colonial Virginia. Your analysis therefore should indicate some of the questions that this source would help answer.It is also important to remember that the authors or creators of any source have their own biases. It is not enough simply to argue that a source is biased. All sources are biased you need to explain what biases are inherent in the source and how the historian should account for them. Lets go  back  to  the  (hypothetical)  Stamp  Act  pamphlet.  Who  is  the  author?  Where  did  he  or  she  come from?  When  is  he  or  she  writing  it?  What  is  he  or  she  trying  to  achieve  by  writing  the  pamphlet? Answering these sorts of questions will give you a full picture of the author of the source and will help make you aware of what biases are present in the source. Your analysis therefore needs to show awareness of context knowledge of the author the time period and the audience will be crucial in achieving strong marks in your assignment.You must also demonstrate the significance of the source you are analyzing. Remember one source alone does not prove anything definitively. (Journalists are told not to report anything unless they have  two  independent  sources  confirming  a  piece  of  information).  Do  not  make  bold  general statements  such  as  this  pamphlet  demonstrates  that  all  Americans  wanted  to  burn  the  King  of England as soon as they heard news of the Stamp Act. Instead explain how the pamphlet criticizes the Stamp Act and then use your wider contextual knowledge to expand further. Can the author be taken seriously? Where might he or she be exaggerating? Is his or her argument too convenient in places? History is the art of critical examination of the past you will need to have a certain level of cynicism to succeed in this course.Finally  you  should  use  your  knowledge  of  the  broader  context  of  the  course  to  explain  why understanding the source is valuable to the historian. Does this source agree with or challenge the interpretations of historians you have read for the course? What sort of historical questions does this source begin to help answer? In what ways does it complicate understandings of the past? This last section will be particularly important in determining your grade. You need to understand the content and context of the source in great detail. But that is only part of the task. You must be able to move beyond a mere description of the source and show analytical skill in explaining how and why it is important to the historian.In summary you will find it helpful to think of the following structure as you write your assignment: Paragraph One Context. What is the source about? Who is the author? Why are they writing it? Paragraph Two Content. What is the specific argument of the source? What does it tell us about the historical event or situation it refers to?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *